I will say that the definition of Jumping the Shark is when you are taken out of the experience. The moment when you realize the original reason you got into the series is gone and everything has changed. The change being so dramatically different and ridiculous it takes you out of the suspension of disbelief. This change not being a growth of the series, but something random that you take negatively.
Plus, we have spent close to two years trying to figure out who the rat is and their motivations. Everyone had their theories and we were finding evidence. Several of us were driven to madness. I was honestly 95% sure the rat was Riley. If this didn't get resolved and thoroughly explained bad things would have happened...blood would have been spilt.
Just because we are looking back doesn't mean we aren't moving forwards.
"That Canadian" - Brittney Brombacher. My official title as of August 8
Author of the first fan script read on We're Not Dead
First Non-American on We're Not Dead
Skittles will be the last survivor
Ch. 28, part 3 - We're back on track again! Great episode! Got my blood pumping like the previous seasons often did.